Sacred Trash

May 26, 2011 in Current Reading | Comments (1)


Sacred Trash: The Lost and Found World of the Cairo Geniza, by Adina Hoffman and Peter Cole, Schocken, New York, 2011.

The story of the Cairo Geniza – that great treasure-trove of documents from the Ben Ezra Synagogue in Old Cairo – is both fascinating and immensely complicated. It is a tale filled with interesting characters, extraordinary coincidences, deplorable errors and astonishing discoveries. I touched upon some aspects of this story in In An Antique Land and I remember thinking at that time: ‘Why hasn’t someone written a book about this? It would read like a thriller.’

Yet I can’t say I was really surprised that such a book had not been written. To call the task formidable would be to greatly understate the case: no one could even think of tackling it without being conversant with medieval Hebrew, Arabic, Aramaic, and a wide range of European languages. In An Antique Land deals with only a small set of Geniza documents – the letters of Abraham Ben Yiju – and it took me years to acquire the necessary linguistic and orthgraphic skills. To write about the full range of Geniza documents – which include not only letters but also liturgical and scriptural texts, poetry, community records and much else – would be far beyond my abilities.

Well, I am glad to say the story of the Geniza has now been told and it does indeed read like a thriller. Sacred Trash is entertaining, lucid, enormously erudite and extremely well-written. Between them the writers possess all the scholarly equipment and narrative gifts that are required for the telling of this tale, and they have done a marvelous job of it.  The Geniza is one of the world’s richest and greatest archives: Adina Hoffman and Peter Cole have given it the biography it deserves.

One Response to “Sacred Trash”

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

  1. Comment by Utpal MukhopadhyayJuly 13, 2011 at 4:51 am   Reply

    Again I have a question. When do you get time to read ? I am re-reading Sea of poppies before I start River of smoke. And I do not have time for anything. Not for the book that I am planning all my life, not the great Avadhi Biriyani that I am trying to make perfect nor practicing that Md. Rafi song that haunts me. Am I missing something in my life? Any hint on time management?

    PS: I was introduced to your Blog by may daughter Malini, who is a fan of your writing. She became one when I made her read ” An antique land” when she was in school in the US.

Leave a Reply


ucuz ukash